top of page


Deken Benjamin McPike Insurance Agency

Our Commitment to Results

As an independent agency, we work for you, not the insurance company - giving you the power of choice. We represent many different insurance companies which offer a wide variety of coverage options and price points. With our connections and knowledge of the market, we can often find a better value for your insurance dollar than you might find searching on your own. We do the shopping. You do the saving. In the end you get the right blend of price, coverage and service.

Who we are

Founded in 1963, Deken Benjamin McPike Insurance Agency writes Commercial and Personal insurance throughout Indiana.


As part of the Union Bay group of companies, Deken Benjamin McPike can offer you even better service and a broader range of insurance choices.  Union Bay has a network of offices and staff throughout the Northeast and Midwest.  More on Union Bay Risk Advisors here.

Our Location

Established in 1963, Deken Benjamin McPike Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency located in Avon, Indiana. For 60 years, Deken Benjamin McPike has been providing clients with comprehensive insurance solutions, one family and business at a time. We make a career out of assessing each client’s unique insurance needs and matching them with the insurance company best equipped to meet those needs at a price that fits the budget.

Our Experience

Deken Benjamin McPike has a strong ethical code of providing the client coverage they need and educating the client about their insurance choices. The licensed staff of the agency continually updates their insurance education and attends seminars to keep them up-to-date on the latest insurance laws, trends, and pertinent topics. Our experienced staff is dedicated to help you navigate the complex world of insurance plans.

Deken Benjamin Favicon (1).png


Robert Beasley.png

Robert Beasley

Licensed Insurance Agent

Michelle Benjamin.png

Michelle Benjamin

Insurance Advisor

Sarah Mann.png

Sarah Mann

Customer Service Rep

Nadia Goldsmith.png

Nadia Goldsmith

Licensed Insurance Agent

Bob McPike.png

Bob McPike

Insurance Advisor

Felicia Duty.png

Felicia Duty

Licensed Insurance Agent

Deken Benjamin Placeholder headshot.png

Patrice McIntosh

Licensed Insurance Agent

Michelle McPike Morin.png

Michelle McPike Morin

Insurance Advisor

Our Team
About Us
bottom of page