Michelle Benjamin

317-271-3900


Michelle Benjamin is the owner of Deken Benjamin Insurance. She has 27 years of experience in the insurance industry. She has owned the agency since 2005 which she purchased from Everett Deken. Michelle enjoys working with her staff and clients daily to figure out insurance solutions that fit everyone’s needs.

Stephanie Buster

317-271-3900


Stephanie is the agency’s Customer Service Agent. Her job is to assist clients with the changes they may need to make to their policies. Stephanie is very knowledgeable in her position and has been with the agency for 12 years.

Taylor Priesthoff, CSA

317-271-3900


Taylor started with Deken Benjamin Insurance in the beginning of 2014. She left our agency in the beginning of 2016 to move south. After some time down south Taylor moved back to the area and back to the agency in 2017. Taylor is licensed and can handle all insurance questions, and servicing along with quoting whatever the customer may need.

Gemma Lou Benjamin


Our Customer Relations Specialist. She started her position here in February and has served in a multitude of functions including bookkeeping, certificates of insurance, and front desk duties. At this point of her career she is now mainly focusing on client relations.